Nobody’s Clicking Google Results Anymore. Here’s What That Means for Your Business.

If you’ve noticed your website traffic feeling a bit flat lately, you’re not imagining it. How search is changing for businesses right now is one of the biggest shifts in digital marketing in years, and most founders haven’t fully clocked it yet. The way people find information online has fundamentally changed, and if your content strategy hasn’t caught up, you could be losing visibility without knowing why.

Google has been rolling out what it calls AI Overviews: those boxes that now appear at the top of search results giving you a summary answer before you’ve even looked at a single website. You’ve probably seen them. You ask a question, Google answers it right there on the page, and you never need to click anywhere.

That sounds convenient as a user. As a business trying to get found online, it’s a very different story.

When AI Overviews appear, click-through rates on the organic results below them have dropped by as much as 64% for position one rankings, according to SeoProfy analysing over 300,000 keywords. Pages that used to get seven or eight clicks out of every hundred searches are now getting closer to two or three. And around 58% of Google searches now end without anyone clicking anything at all.

This isn’t a niche problem affecting a handful of blogs. Some of the biggest media brands in the world are reporting serious traffic losses.

In the UK, Reach (the publisher behind the Daily Mirror, Daily Express, and hundreds of regional papers) saw Google referral traffic fall by around 55% in the first half of 2026, with digital revenue dropping by over £7 million as a result. In the US, USA Today saw its organic Google traffic nearly halved between June 2025 and June 2026. CNN is down around 25%. Business Insider lost more than 85% of its organic search traffic and cut more than a fifth of its workforce.

These are established, well-resourced organisations with dedicated SEO teams. The fact that they’re struggling to adapt tells you something about how significant the shift is.

Even Reddit, a platform Google has historically leaned on heavily as a source of authentic human content, is reportedly weighing up whether to block Google’s AI from accessing its content at all.

Some of the search behaviour that used to go to Google is moving to AI tools directly. ChatGPT’s search function grew its query volume by 340% year on year in 2026, according to research by Nowoka. Perplexity, which works like a search engine built entirely around AI answers, is growing fast too.

What people are doing is asking questions in a more conversational way and expecting a direct answer, not a list of ten blue links to wade through. The search box is being replaced by something that feels more like asking a knowledgeable colleague.

That’s a big shift in behaviour. And it means the way businesses need to think about being found online has to shift with it.

Here’s the honest answer: if your business relies on people finding your website through Google and clicking through to read a blog post or a service page, that model is getting harder. Not impossible, but harder. And understanding how search is changing for businesses is the first step to doing something about it.

The businesses doing well in this new environment are the ones optimising not just for search engines, but for answer engines. That means writing content in a way that AI tools actually want to quote. Direct answers near the top of the page. Question-led headings. Clear, structured information that can be pulled out and cited without needing to visit the page at all.

There’s a term for this: AEO, or Answer Engine Optimisation. It’s been around for a few years but it’s moved from nice-to-have to genuinely important very quickly. The goal isn’t just to rank, it’s to be the source an AI quotes when someone asks a question your business can answer.

The good news is that the core principles aren’t complicated. Write clearly, answer questions directly, be specific, and use the language your customers actually use when they’re searching. Structure your content so a single question gets a single clear answer. The businesses winning citations in AI Overviews and ChatGPT responses tend to be the ones doing those things consistently.

The landscape is shifting fast enough that a lot of businesses haven’t caught up yet. That’s actually an opportunity. Getting your content strategy right now, before your competitors do, puts you in a strong position for how search is likely to look over the next few years.

At Liruss, this is something we’re building into the content work we do for clients already. If you’ve got questions about what it means for your business specifically, we’re always happy to have a chat.

The way people find businesses online is changing. If you’re not sure whether your content is keeping up, that’s a good place to start the conversation. Drop us a message and we’ll take a look.

Drop us a line at hello@liruss.co.uk or find out more about how we work.

What are Google AI Overviews?

Google AI Overviews are AI-generated summary answers that appear at the top of Google search results. They pull information from across the web and present a direct answer to the user’s question, often meaning the user doesn’t need to click through to any website. They rolled out more widely in 2024 and 2025 and now appear in a significant proportion of searches.

Why has my website traffic dropped?

If your organic search traffic has declined recently, Google AI Overviews are one likely factor. Research shows click-through rates on traditional search results can drop by up to 64% when an AI Overview is present. Other contributing factors include broader algorithm updates and changes in how people use search tools. If traffic has dropped noticeably, an audit of your content strategy is a good starting point.

What is AEO and how is it different from SEO?

SEO (Search Engine Optimisation) focuses on getting your pages to rank highly in traditional search results. AEO (Answer Engine Optimisation) focuses on getting your content cited or quoted by AI tools like Google AI Overviews, ChatGPT Search, and Perplexity. The two approaches overlap significantly, but AEO puts more emphasis on direct, clear answers, question-led structure, and content that AI can easily extract and reference.

Do I need to abandon SEO and switch to AEO?

No, and it’s worth being cautious about anyone who says you do. Good SEO still matters, particularly for transactional and commercial searches where AI Overviews appear less often. AEO is an evolution of content best practice, not a replacement. The most effective approach right now is content that works for both, written clearly, structured well, and genuinely useful to the reader.

Are AI search tools like ChatGPT actually replacing Google?

Not yet, and possibly not completely. Google still handles the overwhelming majority of searches globally. But the growth of AI-native search tools is real: ChatGPT Search query volume grew 340% year on year in 2026. The more significant shift is in behaviour, with people increasingly expecting a direct conversational answer rather than a list of links. That change in expectation is what businesses need to plan for.

Scroll to Top